Post subject: lighting for photographing/evaluating color on Imp Topaz
Posted: Mon Dec 18, 2017 8:55 pm
Active Member
Joined: Mon Dec 18, 2017 5:32 pm Posts: 99
Hello I tried posting in another part of the site but it wasn't the right one, hope this is. I am new to gemology and have a hobbyist's interest. I have an Imperial Topaz that I have been trying to photograph and evaluate color on. My question as the title implies is two-fold first what is a good beginning lighting setup for photos and second when looking at the stone what lighting is optimum to evaluate color? I took a few shots with less than satisfying results using my Canon Rebel with 28-300 aspherical macro lens and small light-box with fluorescent squiggle bulbs on either side and then with just an incandescent spot overhead, again with less than stellar results. Any help for this "newbie" would be GREATLY appreciated!
Admin edit:Information from a previous post in the wrong category:
Quote:
Hello, I am new here and gemology in general so please excuse my newbie questions. I inherited a large Imperial Topaz and would like to know what type of lighting is used when evaluating color and photographing to best effect. I took some shots with my Canon Rebel and Tamron 28-300 aspherical macro lens with very unsatisfactory results. I used a small lightbox with a squiggle fluorescent diffused on each side and with just an incandescent spot overhead. I was unimpressed with my results any suggestions?
Post subject: Re: lighting for photographing/evaluating color on Imp Topaz
Posted: Mon Dec 18, 2017 11:04 pm
Active Member
Joined: Mon Dec 18, 2017 5:32 pm Posts: 99
the photo above was under the fluorescent lights as is the one numbered 1712. the other here was under the incandescent spot. the stone was on white foam-core.
That's an interesting stone. I would not have guessed topaz from the photo because of the lack of apparent pleochroism, but it is a real beauty. I suspect it's a combination of two factors. One, the light just isn't intense enough so your background ends up looking kind of grey. The other is that the stone is windowed, and photos are pretty unforgiving to windowed stones in general.
Post subject: Re: lighting for photographing/evaluating color on Imp Topaz
Posted: Tue Dec 19, 2017 8:59 am
Active Member
Joined: Mon Dec 18, 2017 5:32 pm Posts: 99
Isi wrote:
By the way, Rogerg, are you quite sure that this IS an imperial topaz ? Or is it just named so Only asking.
Pretty sure. I was told by one appraiser "it isn't even a stone" so I took it to a lab near me and he tested it several ways and confirmed Topaz and he said it met Imperial standards just not top color. His initial reaction before testing was "nice color" After comparing it to a set of GIA color crystal samples he called it golden orange. I see so much called imperial that is less Salmon than this and that is the reason for the evaluation lighting part to the question. Do gemologists change lighting based on type of material being looked at or is it done under standard lighting? Thanks again all!
Post subject: Re: lighting for photographing/evaluating color on Imp Topaz
Posted: Tue Dec 19, 2017 6:19 pm
Active Member
Joined: Mon Dec 18, 2017 5:32 pm Posts: 99
Stephen Challener wrote:
That's an interesting stone. I would not have guessed topaz from the photo because of the lack of apparent pleochroism, but it is a real beauty. I suspect it's a combination of two factors. One, the light just isn't intense enough so your background ends up looking kind of grey. The other is that the stone is windowed, and photos are pretty unforgiving to windowed stones in general.
The second expert mentioned the windowing as well. Would a re-cut improve it if done by a decent cutter? The stone is 76cts so if worthwile I wouldn't mind doing it I guess. As to the lighting intensity I'll try to add more and try some more shots. Thanks for the input!
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum